Drafting Basic Legal Documents – Answer
This lesson builds upon your previous knowledge of legal writing by focusing on the Answer, a crucial document in the litigation process. You will learn how to respond to the allegations in a complaint, practicing the skills needed to construct a well-written and legally sound Answer.
Learning Objectives
- Identify the purpose and function of an Answer.
- Understand the key components of an Answer.
- Differentiate between admitting, denying, and stating insufficient knowledge to admit or deny an allegation.
- Practice drafting responses to various types of allegations presented in a sample complaint.
Text-to-Speech
Listen to the lesson content
Lesson Content
Introduction to the Answer
The Answer is the defendant's formal response to the plaintiff's complaint. It's the first opportunity for the defendant to address the claims made against them. The Answer provides the court with the defendant’s position on each allegation, setting the stage for the rest of the litigation process. Failure to properly answer a complaint can have serious consequences, potentially leading to a default judgment against the defendant.
Think of it like this: The Complaint presents the plaintiff's story. The Answer tells the defendant's story – or at least, their initial response to the plaintiff's story.
Key Components of an Answer
An Answer typically includes the following components:
- Caption: Same as the complaint; includes the court, case name, and case number.
- Introduction: States the defendant's name.
- Responses to Allegations: This is the heart of the Answer. Each numbered paragraph in the complaint is responded to with one of the following:
- Admit: Agree with the allegation. Usually admits facts, not conclusions of law.
- Example: Complaint Paragraph 1: "Plaintiff resides at 123 Main Street, Anytown, USA." Answer Paragraph 1: "Defendant admits the allegations contained in Paragraph 1."
- Deny: Disagree with the allegation. This means the defendant is asserting the allegation is untrue.
- Example: Complaint Paragraph 5: "Defendant negligently operated his vehicle." Answer Paragraph 5: "Defendant denies the allegations contained in Paragraph 5."
- Deny Insufficient Knowledge to Admit or Deny: The defendant doesn't know enough about the allegation to either admit or deny it. This is appropriate when the defendant lacks personal knowledge.
- Example: Complaint Paragraph 7: "Plaintiff suffered injuries resulting in permanent disability." Answer Paragraph 7: "Defendant lacks sufficient information to admit or deny the allegations contained in Paragraph 7, and therefore denies them." (This is appropriate if the defendant has not reviewed the plaintiff's medical records.)
- Admit: Agree with the allegation. Usually admits facts, not conclusions of law.
- Affirmative Defenses (Optional): These are new facts the defendant brings up that, if proven, could defeat the plaintiff's claim. They come after the responses to allegations and before the prayer for relief.
- Example: "As a first affirmative defense, Defendant alleges that the Plaintiff's claims are barred by the statute of limitations." (The Statute of Limitations is the deadline to bring a lawsuit.)
- Prayer for Relief: This is a short statement requesting that the court dismiss the lawsuit or rule in the defendant's favor.
- Example: "WHEREFORE, Defendant prays that this Court dismiss Plaintiff’s Complaint and award Defendant its costs and attorney’s fees." (This is the ending of the Answer.)
Drafting Responses: Tips and Tricks
Here are some crucial tips for drafting effective responses:
- Be Specific: Do not use vague or generic denials. Reference the complaint's specific paragraph number.
- Be Honest: Do not lie or mislead. Ensure your responses are truthful based on the available information.
- Follow the Complaint: Respond to each and every allegation in the Complaint. Do not skip any.
- Consult with an Attorney: It’s critical to consult with an attorney to review the final Answer before filing it with the court, to ensure the correctness and completeness of the final version.
- Know Your Jurisdiction: Local rules and requirements might vary. Always check with local court rules for format and specific requirements for the Answer.
Deep Dive
Explore advanced insights, examples, and bonus exercises to deepen understanding.
Deep Dive: Nuances in Answering a Complaint
Beyond simply admitting or denying, the art of crafting an Answer involves understanding the subtle implications of each response. Let's explore some less-obvious considerations:
- Affirmative Defenses: An Answer isn't just about responding to the Plaintiff's allegations; it's also your opportunity to introduce affirmative defenses. These are reasons why, even if the Plaintiff's allegations are true, the Defendant is not liable. Common examples include statute of limitations, self-defense, or accord and satisfaction. Failing to raise these in your Answer can result in a waiver, meaning you can't bring them up later.
- Specificity and Detail: While you don't need to provide a complete argument in your Answer, you must provide enough information to put the Plaintiff on notice of the Defendant's position. Vague denials or admissions can be challenged later as insufficient.
- "Insufficient Information" as a Strategy: While it seems like a convenient way to avoid taking a position, claiming insufficient information to admit or deny carries implications. Be prepared to explain why you don't have the information and what steps you've taken to obtain it. Courts often scrutinize this response, especially if the information is readily available.
- Counterclaims and Cross-Claims: The Answer is where the Defendant can assert their own claims against the Plaintiff (counterclaim) or against a co-defendant (cross-claim). This adds another layer of complexity to the document and requires careful consideration of applicable rules and statutes.
Think Like a Lawyer: Every word in an Answer is important. Consider the potential implications of each statement. Is the response factually accurate, legally sound, and strategically advantageous? Your responses should set the stage for discovery and trial.
Bonus Exercises
Sharpen your skills with these additional practice activities:
Exercise 1: Drafting Affirmative Defenses
Review the sample complaint you've been using. Assume the lawsuit involves a car accident. Based on the allegations, identify potential affirmative defenses the Defendant might raise. Then, draft brief statements (one or two sentences) for two such defenses that could be included in the Answer. For example, "Defendant asserts the Plaintiff's claims are barred by the statute of limitations."
Exercise 2: Analyzing Ambiguity
Review a complaint or a sample Answer online. Identify at least three statements where the language could be interpreted in multiple ways. Explain the potential ambiguities and how they could be addressed to create clarity.
Real-World Connections
Understanding the Answer is more than just a legal exercise; it has practical implications in everyday scenarios:
- Insurance Claims: When filing an insurance claim, providing accurate and specific information is crucial. Your responses to questions during the claim process are analogous to the responses in an Answer. The insurance company relies on this information to assess liability and coverage.
- Contract Disputes: Reviewing a contract and understanding your obligations, or defending against a breach of contract claim, requires the same analytical skills used when drafting an Answer.
- Professional Correspondence: The ability to clearly articulate your position and respond to accusations in a professional manner is a valuable skill in any field. The Answer serves as a model for clear, concise, and strategic communication.
Challenge Yourself
Ready to push your limits? Try these advanced tasks:
- Research Local Rules: Research and summarize the local rules of a court in your jurisdiction regarding the formatting and content requirements for Answers.
- Simulate a Motion to Strike: Using a sample Answer, draft a hypothetical "Motion to Strike" based on a specific paragraph. Explain the grounds for your motion.
Further Learning
Expand your knowledge with these YouTube resources:
- How to Answer a Summons and Complaint in California — Explains the process of answering a complaint in California, a specific jurisdiction.
- Answering a Complaint | The Litigation Process Explained — Provides a general overview of the answer and the litigation process.
- Affirmative Defenses Explained — Discusses the importance and different types of affirmative defenses.
Interactive Exercises
Practice: Responding to Allegations
Imagine you are the paralegal for the defendant. The following are excerpts from a hypothetical complaint. For each, draft a response (Admit, Deny, or Deny Insufficient Knowledge). 1. Plaintiff alleges that on June 1, 2023, the Defendant’s vehicle struck the Plaintiff’s vehicle at the intersection of Elm Street and Oak Avenue. 2. Plaintiff alleges that the Defendant was driving under the influence of alcohol at the time of the collision. 3. Plaintiff alleges that the Defendant’s vehicle was insured by ABC Insurance Company. 4. Plaintiff alleges that Plaintiff suffered severe emotional distress. 5. Plaintiff alleges that the collision caused property damage to Plaintiff’s vehicle exceeding $10,000.
Reflection: Common Mistakes
Reflect on common mistakes that a paralegal might make when drafting an Answer. Consider what could happen if these mistakes are made.
Exercise: Identifying Affirmative Defenses
For each of the following scenarios, identify a potential affirmative defense: 1. The plaintiff filed the lawsuit three years after the alleged injury. 2. The plaintiff was also at fault for the accident, contributing to the incident. 3. The defendant has already paid the plaintiff a settlement.
Practical Application
Imagine you are a paralegal in a personal injury law firm. Your supervisor has given you a copy of a complaint, and you are tasked with drafting a preliminary Answer. You must research how to answer a complaint in your jurisdiction, including any specific local rules, and use the provided information to create a draft Answer for review.
Key Takeaways
The Answer is the defendant's initial response to the plaintiff's complaint.
The Answer typically includes the defendant's admission, denial, or response of insufficient information to each allegation.
Affirmative defenses are raised in the Answer and may prevent the plaintiff from winning the case.
Thorough and accurate drafting of the Answer is crucial to protect the defendant's interests.
Next Steps
Review the basic elements of the complaint and Answer and be ready to learn about discovery.
Your Progress is Being Saved!
We're automatically tracking your progress. Sign up for free to keep your learning paths forever and unlock advanced features like detailed analytics and personalized recommendations.
Extended Learning Content
Extended Resources
Extended Resources
Additional learning materials and resources will be available here in future updates.